Submitting to Egalitarianism: One Couple’s Journey

Tammi Kauffman

lightstock_329212_medium_andrewpeters

Subscribe to the Junia Project Blog

Get content on biblical equality straight to your inbox.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Submitting to Egalitarianism- One Couple's Journey

I should have realized it long before; I should have recognized the signs. But I didnt. I suppose I was so lost in my own ideas that I didnt notice. My husband and I were both raised in complementarian or patriarchal homes. We were taught that the man was the head of the home, the priest and leader of the family and that the woman was to submit to his leadership. He was wise to take her counsel, but the ultimate decision lay with him. He, as the man, made the final decision. And the wife submitted.

Soon after our 8th anniversary, we began homeschooling our children. The homeschooling community is, by and large, staunchly patriarchal. I threw myself into the whole scene. Women were to be raised to be keepers at home; there would be no careers for my daughters. I still remember my 5-year-old daughter throwing herself on the couch in tears when she realized I didnt support her desire to become a doctor.

During this time, I was staunchly against women in any type of leadership, particularly in the church. I even wondered at what point it became unbiblical for me to teach my own sons. I wrestled with the hypothetical dilemma of voting between a male Democrat and a female Republican. On one home school social media site, I argued vehemently with a gentleman (oh, the irony) that women should not preach; the Bible was clear on it.

I discussed this with my husband. He thought it ridiculous that women could share on a topic behind a podium on a Sunday evening but she could not deliver the same topic behind the pulpit on a Sunday morning. I argued with him. “The pulpit is differentits holier somehow.” He wasnt convinced. To him, it revealed the absurdity of man-made rules. Its a sermonshes preachingshes teaching men. If its OK in the oneits OK in the other.

We agreed to disagree and I continued my journey into patriarchy. But despite my most valiant efforts, I failed miserably. I couldnt measure up to the expectations patriarchy placed upon me. I was slowly dying inside.  My husband was discouraged by my journey. He felt like we were heading in two opposite directions. I thought this was what he wanted: a submissive wife who took good care of him, his children, and his home! But he did not like watching his wife slowly die inside, and the whole system did not sit well with him.

He wanted a wife who was equal to him, not under him. A few years later, I got involved in ministry outside the home and went back to school. While I enjoyed every bit of it, I felt guilty because he was home with the kids while I was off doing ministry.  This was not the way things were supposed to be!! Im supposed to stay home with the kids while he does ministry. Yet, he delighted in seeing his wife blossom and develop her gifts. His wife was coming alive again!

I began to realize that while I was miserable at domestic skills and stereotypical female roles, I excelled in at least one that was reserved for men: preaching and teaching.  Teaching and preaching made me feel as if I was born for this. My soul came back to life!  

This started me on a different journey.  I began wrestling with this whole “women in ministry” thing. How could something forbidden to women bring me such life? Why was I so talented at something God didnt permit me to do? One of the first books I read was Powerful and Free by Danny Silk. In the book, the author describes some of his wife’s sentiments, including being uncomfortable with a model for marriage in which the husband has absolute veto power. This means that, in the process of making a decision, the husband can choose whether or not to seek or follow his wifes counsel. This didnt feel right to me and I shared it with my husband. What value was there in my opinion anyway if he could veto it anytime he wanted??!!

He had no clue what I was talking about. “Absolute veto power? I dont have absolute veto power.” Yes you do. You can decide if youll follow my ideas or your own. You get to be the one who decides if my advice is worthy of following. You get to choose whether its my way or your way. I dont have that choice. You have the veto power on any decision. You get to make executive orders that I have to follow. I dont have that power.” But that didnt describe our marriage to him. It was the marriage I had tried to create, not him. He would never consider making a decision on which we did not agree.

On that day, I realized I had married an egalitarian. My husband truly believed in gender equality; he wanted me to have equal say in decisions. If we couldnt come to an agreement, one of us, and not always the same one, would defer. I would defer to him or he would defer to me. To be honest, hes probably the one who defers more often. There are times I leadand times he leads. There are situations in which I submitand those in which he submits. There are decisions I makedecisions he makesdecisions we make.

In my foray into patriarchy, I didn’t see the impact it had on my husband. It’s obvious that patriarchy demands certain things of women and I was not that woman. But it also demands certain things of men…and my husband was not that man. He leads, but as a servant and co-leader, not as one with final authority. During that time, he felt like he was not the man I wanted or needed him to be. He didn’t have a big vision or goals or dreams or mission that I could get behind and support.

Patriarchy and complementarianism forced both of us into boxes that didn’t fit well.

Now Im the one with dreams and goals and visions and he supports me. He is my biggest fan. When I feel like quitting because it feels selfish to take so much time away from family, or because the house is always a mess, hes the one who encourages me to keep going. He comes alongside me in ministry. He loves to hear me preach. He also critiques my preaching and teaching, helping me improve. If the day ever comes when I pastor a church, he will be as glad to see that as I will be. 

It took a while. Egalitarianism is such a loaded term with lots of negative baggage. But, after years of doing my own thing, I finally submitted to my husbands leadership and became an egalitarian.

Tammi Kauffman

Personal Stories, Women and the Church

Those Who Protect a Woman’s Call

Sarah Sparks-Franklin

Thank God for those who protect a woman’s call! “I’m not sure I can continue…

General

Awaiting the Refugee King: A Christmas Reflection

Christiana Rice

This Christmas, I’m pondering the grittier, truer side of the nativity narrative through the lens

Women and the Church

12 Ways to Advocate for Women in Ministry

Elizabeth Graham

I am a part of a Christian tradition that has ordained women as elders since…

Subscribe for our free guide

7 Things your church should know about Biblical Equality

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

14 Comments

  • I loved your article. My husband (Bill) and I had been married for over thirty years. A few years back we went to a marriage seminar and heard the typical story of a husband making the final decision when wife was opposed, and of course, later the submissive wife was “thrilled” with the decision. On the way home I realized that had never happened to us. Bill never had to pull “I’m head of household” card. We never had a disagreement that we didn’t resolve with both of us happier than if one of us got our own way. So I wondered was our marriage “Biblical”?

    Spring a year ago our women’s Bible study was on the epistles of Timothy. When I read 1 Timothy 2:12, I said to myself, “Wait a minute. What’s going on here? This isn’t what Paul usually says.” That caused me to do research and I discovered the Junia Project. Wow! I realized that Bill and I had been practicing the equalitarian marriage all along.

  • Tammi, I was raised like you were. My first marriage was complementarian, and it failed miserably.
    It bothered me that we were supposed to be partners, but it would be a poor business partnership if one partner could arbitrarily veto the others proposals. A partnership in business like that would always fail. It didn’t make sense to me.
    My second marriage has now lasted four times as long as my first, and it is egalitarian. I have a ministry, and he is proud of me, and supports me in every way.
    God bless you in your ministry.

    • No one would want a business partnership in which both parties don’t have full voice yet that’s what we think works for marriage. Not well thought out, I’d say. I’m glad for you that your husband is supportive and treats you as an equal. Prayers for many happy years together!

  • I ” SO ” went through the SAME journey…this is hilarious. I too thought my husband would prefer me to always be the submittant if there is such a word…in the end, despite him being very dominant, he didn’t like the atmosphere in the Complementarian church we attended…he got to dislike the attitude toward women…and in the end, even though I had no problem with it after 30 years, I realized how unfair it was. Well God is nothing if not impeccably just so that got me thinking…and thinking…within 3 years I realized that God didn’t prefer men, didn’t treat men as mediators between women and God and that “there is only one mediator” even though I have had pastors tell me they are mediators, my husband is a mediator…they don’t see the dichotomy between their view and their Bible that says only Christ can be a mediator…that got me thinking “where does God EVER address a woman through her man?” NO WHERE, THAT’S WHERE. Every reference to God or his angels addressing women he never addresses them through their fathers, husbands or other authorities but DIRECTLY…That opened my eyes…after “Is not My way equal?” saith the LORD? Ezekiel 18, Ezekiel 33…4 x. “Is not your way unequal? Yes God is right!

    • You are so right about that! God speaks directly to women, even commissioning them to speak to others. It is interesting how similar the stories of people are in this journey called marriage.

    • Thank you! I’m glad that my story can encourage others.

  • Tammi, you articulate so well your journey and the realities of the of the equality complementarians say they believe in. If one person can veto another person’s decisions that person does not have autonomy or personal agency, which contradicts the whole concept of equality! Thank for sharing your story.

    • Thank you. I’ll never forget the confused look on my husband’s face as I insisted he had absolute veto power and explained it to him. It was,so foreign to him. It is so true that that contradicts the idea of equality.

  • Wow, what a life journey you have had. Thanks for sharing. It is always good to hear when we are able to grow and learn and move toward thriving for all as God intends for us. I am thankful for your experience and men like your husband, and the way God reveals truth – through others, through scripture, through life experiences, through reasoning, and through curious, reflective-thinking minds.

    • I enjoy hearing other’s stories as well. It is so encouraging and humbling as well. It increases the grace I give others and myself.

  • I think your story echoes so much of what women go through – we want to buy into the patriarchal system but our soul dies inside whenever we do so. Without all the fancy terms, thank God for men like your husband and also for God’s wisdom.

    • Yes! My heart aches for the women still trying to live in a system that deprives them of that which breathes life into them. I am very thankful for the support of my husband.

Comments are closed.

Scroll to Top