8 Ways to Rethink the Conversation About Singleness

Karina Kreminski

lightstock_329212_medium_andrewpeters

Subscribe to the Junia Project Blog

Get content on biblical equality straight to your inbox. And get our free guide: 5 Pillars of Biblical Equality

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Rethinking Singleness in the church

 

Rethinking Singleness in the church

These days there is more emphasis on marriage and family than ever.

My social media feeds are full of articles and posts about gay marriage, sex in couple relationships, the struggles and joys around creating a healthy Christian marriage, the sadness of miscarriage, the intricacies of parenting, the wars around household chores. I could go on and on. This is all fine, but my concern is that articles about healthy marriage abound whereas articles around healthy singleness are much less popular.

Interestingly, the debate about gay marriage has served to harden traditional evangelical views around marriage. Fear is growing among many Christians that unless we protect the institution of marriage our civilization, as we know it, is in peril. I think this is partly what is behind the many books and articles being written about marriage.

Ironically, this is happening at a time when we should not be focusing on marriage but on singleness.

I can understand the gravitation towards a fixation on marriage; I can even understand that this relationship is very important to God, so it is worth investing in and nurturing. But I can’t fully comprehend the present obsession with the marriage relationship.

Demographic studies show that singles (adults never married, divorced, or widowed) make up from 24-51% of population in the Western world. Even those who choose to marry are doing so later (age 29 for men, 27 for women), so they are single for the first decade of adulthood.

At a time when more people than ever are choosing to be single or simply end up that way, at a time when the church is telling people with a homosexual orientation that they must remain celibate, at a time when singleness should be encouraged as a viable option for serving God’s mission in the world, evangelicals are fixated on the marriage relationship.

I think this conversation needs more attention.  So here are some thoughts around how we can be more inclusive of singles and change the conversation around singleness today.

1. Recognize the privilege that married people with children hold

My friends keep telling me how hard it is to be married and have children. I agree with them. I am a pastor so I know about the struggles married people have. In counselling sessions with church members I hear about the difficulties that surround the intimate sharing of two lives. My married with young children friends are some of the most stressed out people I know.  However, people who are married with children are the norm in society almost in every way possible.

Food is packaged for people married with children, government policies are designed around them. Sermons focus on marriage development and marriage retreats are given priority. We celebrate marriage, births, and anniversaries with social media posts and parties. The idealized and sometimes idolized trajectory of life is marriage, having kids, owning a house, retirement, and then the enjoyment of grand kids. This progresses to our twilight years being spent together reminiscing nostalgically about the past. There’s nothing wrong with this narrative. I just wish alternatives stories were promoted more in society.

Living differently from this normative cultural narrative can be just as fulfilling, rewarding, and challenging.

When we persist in marginalizing alternative narratives it’s no wonder we see so much loneliness, grief, FOMO syndrome (fear of missing out), and despair prevailing in our communities. Married couples with children carry a privilege they need to be aware of regardless of the difficulties they face in life.

2. Include people who are single in your family life

Perhaps because many families are stressed out and feel threatened by life they tend to withdraw and internalize. The focus becomes the maintenance of the immediate family and if there is room for anything else, it might be other families who are similar.

It is a myth that single people do not want to connect with families.

Sure, sometimes the conversation around nappies, schools, and sickness can get a tad monotonous, but it brings an important dimension to the lives of single people. Singles need to reach out to families and families need to share their lives with singles who need the support and strength that comes from the comfort of the family system.

3. Resist idolizing the nuclear family

I have already implied that our society idolizes the nuclear family. I think this happens even more so in the church. Family life is sacred and to be protected from intruders at all cost. When I was pastoring the most common objection to involvement in ministry went something like, “We are spending time with the family and so cannot give more to the church”. To impede on that family time was a sin.

Think of the perfect image of the senior pastor or youth pastor. Usually that picture will be a man with a supportive wife and children. Anything outside of that picture signals complication, discomfort, and even confusion. How did we get to be this way?

Church history tells us that celibacy was once the norm for ministers, saints, nuns, and monks.

Even though the Desert Fathers have been exalted in church history, there is now a re-visioning of this narrative which more accurately conveys the work of Desert Mothers, usually single, who made a substantial contribution to the mission of the church. I am thankful for this re-visioning. Married people with children will always be the norm, but we can work to make sure single people do not feel excluded and marginalized. 

4. Rediscover Trinitarian theology

Many theologians are courageously delving into Trinitarian theology and thinking about how we can ‘apply’ the Trinity. As we look at the dynamics we see that the three in one are community in deep relationship with each other.  If we are made in the image of God, then we are also relational and interdependent rather than independent human beings. We need each other, and more, we long for each other because we have community stamped into our DNA.

If this is true then we need to seriously think about doing community better as God’s church. Where else can there be bold witness to the image of God but through the church as we reflect that image? True community means that all are included and no one is marginalized. Married and single people worship together in the presence of and bearing witness to Father, Son and Holy Spirit.

5. Pay attention to the specific concerns of single people

One myth still being perpetuated is that single people have more time on their hands, so times of rest and refreshment come more easily than to married with children people. This is not true. Many single people, especially if they have heard the call of God to forsake marriage normativity, are often stressed, lonely, and over committed. Sometimes this simply comes with the burden of living lives worthy of the call, but other times this can be a pressure that is too heavy for single people. We need friends who care enough to intentionally check in on us to make sure we are not over-committed. Don’t assume that a single person has these kinds of friends in her or his life.

6. Stop being fearful of people who are single

This may sound a little dramatic, but I think many people are fearful of single people. Sometimes it can be a fear that comes from confusion or puzzlement. “I wonder why they are single?” I often hear people say. Instead of coming closer to the person, withdrawal happens as that person is seen as different or is even treated suspiciously.

As a woman I am sometimes accused of being “careerist” and too selfish to think about marriage and children.

I also get told that I am too independent. Sometimes I am thought of suspiciously by wives who are worried about predatory-like behavior from me towards their husbands, or alternatively, unfaithful behavior from the husband. I think that single men face prejudice on another level altogether and support networks are even more difficult for them. Let’s break through some of these unhelpful suspicions and fear and see the humanity that lies in each of us; then treat each other with respect and compassion.   

7. Develop a more thoughtful ecclesiology

If we believe that the church is the embodiment of the good news of the gospel in our world, then we need to incorporate a more thoughtful view of community in the church. I am surprised by how often the image of community is left out in usual pictures of the church.

We emphasize the family image but have contaminated that notion with un-biblical and prejudiced paradigms.

For example, church traditions that teach that a woman’s God-ordained role in life is to be a wife and mother at home communicate that women are somehow “less then” or settling for second best if they remain single.

We need to peel back these prejudices and think together about what it means to be true community as the church. I have written more about my frustration with the church’s practice of community here: http://www.missioalliance.org/stop-using-word-community-unless-mean-part-one/

8. Employ people who are single in ministry

I have faced prejudice as a single person in ministry. Often single people are not considered for roles because it is thought they will not be able to understand the issues married people face.  Should not the church be a little more countercultural than this?

Single people are more prone to economic disadvantage, so the church should be employing more single people if possible. There is no good reason to not employ a single person if there is a biblical view of team within the ministry of the church. As we complement each other, each person’s gifts support and shape the overall mission of the church. As married people and single serve together, the body of Christ works harmoniously and mutually.

As I re-read this I wonder if I have been too vocal, too harsh.

I ask myself if I have come across as a victim or whether I have been unfair to married people with children. I hope not. I have great hope in God’s church. His Spirit is at work to purify reform, refine, and transform us into a people who are counter to the values of this world. I am thankful for those who are writing about and intelligently raising awareness around singleness for our times.

May God’s Spirit continue writing the story of the kingdom through us, and may that story bear evidence to the glory of God’s church in the times in which we live.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Notes on Population Data

  1. For the first time, half of the American adult population are single….it’s really just the US catching up with Europe (more especially, Northern Europe) where this has been true for some decades now. Germany, France and Britain have a greater proportion of one-person households than the United States, as does Japan. Three of the nations with the fastest-growing populations of single people — China, India and Brazil — are also among those with the fastest growing economies. September 2014 Forbes/The U.S. Is Becoming More European: Half of Adult Americans Are Now Single
  2. One in four Australian households is a lone-person household, and rates have increased sharply since the 1970s. The Australian rate (24%) is similar to those of other English-speaking countries, which all have rates ranging from 22% (New Zealand) to 29% (the UK). March 2015. Australian Institute of Family Studies/Demographics of living alone
  3. The average age for first marriage in the U.S. is age 29 for men and age 27 for women. http://blogs.census.gov/2014/02/10/marrying-older-but-sooner/)

More on Singleness in the Church

8 articles on singleness on the Junia Project website

Singleness and women in the church by Katelyn Beaty

A Liberation Theology for Single People by Christena Cleveland

Singleness: Theology, Spirituality, and Practice sponsored by Fuller Seminary, Phoenix, AZ May 6-7, 2016

Karina Kreminski

Personal Stories, Women and the Church

Those Who Protect a Woman’s Call

Sarah Sparks-Franklin

Thank God for those who protect a woman’s call! “I’m not sure I can continue…

General

Awaiting the Refugee King: A Christmas Reflection

Christiana Rice

This Christmas, I’m pondering the grittier, truer side of the nativity narrative through the lens

Women and the Church

12 Ways to Advocate for Women in Ministry

Elizabeth Graham

I am a part of a Christian tradition that has ordained women as elders since…

Subscribe for our free guide

5 Pillars of Biblical Equality

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

12 Comments

  • Under the #5, the specific concerns of single people, can I add the need to talk about sex? As a single person, having an unmet sexual desire is sometimes frustrating. This struggle is not just for heterosexual single people, but even more so for homosexual people who, in the conservative Christian ethic, are asked to remain celibate their entire lives. Things like masturbation and pornography, and keeping our minds in Christ are really important, even if they seem off-putting. Since we are called to live counter-culturally, Christian singles should not be getting their sexual ethics from mainstream television or their secular co-workers.

    • Thanks for that Joy. I agree with you. This is topic we need to explore. I was going to write a follow up blog and call it some thing like “Stop asexualizing singles”. There is nothing wrong with being asexual but the problem is when we assume that for all singles. We need to have a broader view of sexuality for this to happen. And then yes as you say explore some more of those topics which don’t get talked about very much.

  • It really bothers me when Christians try to tell people they’re not worthy if they’re single. Regardless of whether or not you’re an egalitarian, there’s no denying that 1 Corinthians 7 says being single is a gift. It’s especially insulting to me, an asexual woman, who wants to get married but doesn’t want to have sex. I may not be able to find a husband who’s as serious about his faith as me but has no desire for sexual intimacy.

  • I had 2 marriage proposals before the age of 20. One didn’t appreciate me wanting to go to college, the other was viciously abusive. Would God want me in either situation? I don’t think so. Young women are told subconsciously that they are somehow less Christian, not following God’s plan or that there is something horribly wrong with you if you are not married. The Southern Baptist Convention wonders why their numbers are shrinking? Women don’t want to feel the pressure.

  • This blog post encapsulates many of the themes and topics I address on my own blog and have been addressing over the last few years on that blog (“Christian Pundit” blog on Word Press).

    I did want to say one thing I think the author of this post overlooked but that I mention on my blog. While it is mostly true that many conservative Christians tend to overlook adult singles – they worship marriage and the nuclear family – there are some portions among conservative Christians who have in fact noticed that more and more adults are not marrying. or not marrying until later in life.

    Consequently, these Christians (such as Al Mohler of the Southern Baptists) started promoting something called “early marriage” a few years ago, as well as making speeches and blog posts demonizing adult singleness, or making singleness sound “second rate” as compared to marriage.

    What these Christians do under the early marriage rubric is nag, harass, shame, or criticize Christian singles into marrying, and preferably, marrying young (they tend to be ageist: they don’t even care about singles who are single past the age of 30).

    These early marriage Christian advocates also tend to assume, quite wrongly, that all to most singles are single because they choose to be.

    While it may be true that a lot of singles are single due to choice these days – and I am sorry I don’t have any stats to cite – I am aware of many, many Christian single women who very much want to marry but were unable to because they never met the right man.

    Such single women are NOT single because they were too enamored of their career, or because they hate men, or because they hate marriage.

    However, a lot of Christians who promote early marriage tend to assume single Christian women are intentionally choosing to forgo marriage due to such reasons. I don’t think these early marriage proponents realize how hurtful and grating their assumptions are to women who did, and who still do, want to marry, but have been unable to.

    I have a blog hosted on Word Press called “Christian Pundit” where I cover all of the topics mentioned in this post, and a few others. I’m not sure if we are permitted to put links in our posts here, but if so, here is a link to the home page of my blog, where I’ve been discussing how most Christians marginalized adult singles and either ignore or insult adult, childless singles: Christian Pundit Blog – covering Christianity and Adult Singleness, among other topics

    • Thanks for making that excellent point.

  • Thank you for this, Karina. As a fellow single woman, I’m very thankful that you wrote this. The idea of married privilege is coming up a lot for me lately, and it’s been a gift to have married friends admit to it. We have a long road to go, but I know that God wants good things for single people and for us to be able to enter fully into the community of faith.

  • I went to high school and college in the ’70’s. I had to change denominations to get away from the stigma of “if you aren’t married by 20 there is something wrong with you”. God called me to be a RN. That was my mission
    After I graduated and started working, I would run into people from my old church who would say things like “Oh don’t worry, you will get married soon” Many of my friends from the old church married the first guy that came along and several of them had disastrous marriages. Three of my friends were victims of domestic violence and one had a husband who refused to work. The idea that you have to be married by a certain can be dangerous for the body and psyche as well as the heart.

  • Having spent a good chunk of my life single, I resonate with this article. To me, one of the potentially damaging narratives is that marriages go through ups and downs and you just have to hang in there, with the accompanying implication that divorce meant you were impatient or didn’t try hard enough. Sometimes what’s good stays good and what is bad stays bad, so there’s little hope that sticking in there is the answer. As well, the narrative around being single is so often around those who chose to be single, not those who just ended up that way not by choice. It doesn’t feel holy, it feels, as you say, like being left out of what other people seem to have achieved. There is a delicate balance between encouraging staying in marriage to work things out and recognizing when that is destructive to both partners. And there is a balance between celebrating those who choose a single life and make good use of it and acknowledging the frustration and sadness of those for whom it was not a choice and who are trying to make lemonade from a lot of lemons.

    • @ Judy Purvis.
      I’ve been blogging about many of the same subjects on my Christian Blog the last few years that this blog post discusses. If you click on the “Christian Pundit” name in this comment’s heading, it should take you to my blog’s home page.

      One of the few issues I did not see this blog post address was “early marriage,” something which some Christians have been advocating the last few years, which heavily pressures adult singles to marry and marry very young. It also conveys the message that there is something wrong, sinful, or second rate about being single past the age of 29.

      I had wanted to marry, but it just never happened for me, and I’m over 40 now. I get deeply annoyed or angry over the Christian penned articles (usually by the “early marriage” guys) who ASSUME that all of us who are single past 30 or 40 deliberately set out to be single, or because we were too obsessed with a career, or whatever. They seldom acknowledge that some of us are single against our choice or hopes.

    • @ Judy Purvis, I agree. Christians need a new narrative about marraigeand we need to do away with the myth that self-preservation is an un-Christian characteristic, especially in a marriage. We are looking for martyrs…we’d rather have people dead and married than alive and leaving a marriage for their sanity, safety, or health.

Comments are closed.

Scroll to Top